ESSAY · October 30, 2026 · 4 MIN READ

The Best Seat on Sixth Avenue

Pop-art illustration of a red-haired woman watching a Halloween parade of Thriller zombies and a skeletal puppet on Sixth Avenue; her speech bubble says “FINALLY.”

New York, Halloween, and the one night I wasn't the most dressed-up person on the block.

Last week I told you I don't dress up. I came as myself, I hate costume parties, look at my shoes. All true. I also said there was exactly one place where that never made me the odd one out.

It was New York, on Halloween night.

Front row

If you've never been to the Village Halloween Parade, here's the short version: the entire city shows up to see who's lost their mind most beautifully this year, and the answer is everyone.

Most people watch it from ten deep along the route, on tiptoe, catching glimpses of giant puppets between strangers' heads. Through a friend, we got to know the parade's organizer, which meant we got to stand in the media section. No crowd, no craning. Just the full insanity of New York in costume, coming straight at us, close enough to see the glue.

It was the best seat I've ever had for anything, and I've had some seats.

A hundred people, one dance

Then came the Thriller dancers.

If you haven't seen it: a hundred-odd people, zombies, every one of them, doing the dance from the video in perfect sync down the middle of the avenue. Some of them were my friends. People with jobs and leases and inboxes learned choreography in advance so they could perform it exactly once, in the dark, for strangers.

That's the most New York thing I know. Not the costumes. The commitment. A whole city that, given one night and a bit, will rehearse the bit.

The exception

In the interest of full disclosure, there was one year I tried.

I was going for Desperate Housewife of New Jersey. Big hair, bigger jewelry, a certain marital desperation in the eyeliner. I don't know exactly where it went wrong. Somewhere between the hair and the lashes, I crossed a line I didn't know was there, and I ended up looking much more like a drag queen.

In most cities, that's a costume failure. In New York, that's a promotion.

That was the only time I dressed up for Halloween in New York on purpose, and the city graded it generously. I took it as a sign.

The one night everyone caught up

Here's what I understood standing in that media section, watching a hundred zombies hit their marks: in New York, Halloween was the one night everyone else dressed like I do every day. All of it out on the street, intentional and overdone and proud of it.

For one night a year, I wasn't too much. I was the baseline. The whole city came as somebody, and for once, coming as myself was the most normal thing on Sixth Avenue.

Now

Now I'm in Denver, where there's no Sixth Avenue and nobody's rehearsing anything. What Denver has instead is my friend Chocolatina, The Pie Queen, and with her, dressing up for Halloween isn't a suggestion. It's a summons.

So I have to amend the record. The woman who hates costume parties, who came as herself, who wrote you an entire field guide about it last week, went as Cruella de Vil last year.

In my defense, look at who I chose. A villain whose whole personality is a coat. I didn't so much put on a costume as turn up the volume on the one I already wear.

Here's what I've figured out. In New York, the whole city dressed up, so I never had to. I could stand in the front row as myself and still belong to the parade. Denver doesn't throw that kind of parade. So instead, somebody who loves you drags you into being one.

Maybe that's the thing I missed about New York and the thing I found here, and maybe they were always the same thing: someone making sure I show up in something.

This year's costume? Ask me Saturday.

A flamingo perched on hot-pink sunglasses beside a lipstick.